★Personal experience with banking concept of education Essay …
- Assignment one freire “banking Concept”
Response to Freire’s The “Banking” Concept of Education
When I read ‘The Banker Concept’ by Freire it reminded me of high school. In my high school classes my teacher would lecture the entire class and students being “listening objects.” I believe that lecturing the whole class period can be good with taking notes and memorizing the material covered but for the most part I prefer classroom interaction because I learn better if I participate in discussions and sharing opinions.
In his essay The Banking Concept of Education, Freire expounds on the mechanical flaw in the current system, and offers an approach that he believes medicates the learning-teaching disorder in the classroom. The flawed conception, Freire explains, is the oppressive “depositing” of information (hence the term ‘banking’) by teachers into their students. But, according to Freire, a “liberating” educational practice (his problem-posing method.
The “banking concept,” as termed by Freire, is essentially an act that hinders the intellectual growth of students by turning them into, figuratively speaking, comatose “receptors” and “collectors” of information that have no real connection to their lives.
“Implicit in the banking concept is the assumption of a dichotomy between human beings and the world: a person is merely in the world, not with the world or with others; the individual is a spectator, not re-creator. In this view the person is not a conscious being ; he or she is rather the possessor of a consciousness: an empty “mind” passively open to the reception of deposits of reality from the world outside” (260)
What Freire means by this is that the banking concept impose between a person (teacher and/or student) and the “real world”, resulting in the evident of his or her true consciousness, since the former can only be realized through the relationships and connections the individual draws from the material to their life.
In this approach the roles of students and teachers become less structured, and both engage enrichment to effectively ascertain knowledge from each other.
According to Freire, “Knowledge emerges only through invention and re-invention, through the restless, impatient, continuing, hopeful inquiry human beings pursue in the world, with the world, and with each other”(257)
enables teachers and students to become Subjects of the educational process by overcoming authoritarianism and an alienating intellectualism” (258-259).
“students and teachers actually “discovering” knowledge with and from each other, because the teacher poses a question but already has the solution in mind. In this way, the students are directed towards a particular outcome, and do not have independent thought-processes or the teacher poses a question with no intention of steering the dialogue towards a single answer, but it is the remaining percent of answers, which they had never actually considered, that they in fact take interest in..”
In which I have experienced this form of education in and outside school my whole life even in college. “Education is suffering from narration sickness” (256)
The two types of education are important because of what they imply about the conext, purpose, and effects of education, not just because of what happens in the classroom.
” Many students interpret banking education to be synonymous with classrooms where there are lecture, where students are expected to memorize and regurgitate, where facts are taught. They often say math, sciences, and languages must be banked, or that elementary school must be banking. They see problem-posing classrooms as ones where students have discussion, sharing their opinions, being creative.”
I would agree that most of my college career has been based on the problem-posing system due to this quote having discussions, sharing opinions, and more hands on learning.
Paulo Freire compares two concepts of education, banking and problem-posing. In banking teachers assume students are passive, take all control, determine what will be learned, and “force-feed” information to students. ” The world is seen as static; students are encouraged to “fit in to” the world as it is”. ” Banking encourages students to accept the world as it is, separates the learner and the learner’s consciousness from the world, and so contributes to oppression.” In problem-posing, students and teachers carry on a dialogue to teach one another. The world is seen as always in the process of becoming; students are seen as parts of that. Students are therefore active, becoming empowered to criticize the world and so change it. “Problem-posing thereby results in the liberation of the students and in the revolution against oppressive social and economic systems.” Problem-posing education allows people to develop their human natures fully because it depends on (communication), and recognizes the relationship between people and the world,”encourages inquiry”, and leads to transformation in students life’s.
Post your own or leave a trackback: Trackback URL
- Nate says:September 16, 2011 at 9:19 pm
Great essay and awesome format. I like all your examples/ references, great tool to understand on what you were talking bout.Reply
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
- Free Essays
- Free Essay Checker
- Free Grammar Checker
- About Us
- Contact Us
- Terms Conditions
- Hire Writer
- Log In
- Free Essays
- Free Essay Checker
- Free Grammar Checker
- About Us
- Contact Us
- Terms Conditions
- Hire Writer
- Log In
Parsons College > Free Essays > Paulo Freire “The Banking Concept of Education” Essay Sample
Paulo Freire “The Banking Concept of Education” Essay Sample
“The Banking Concept of Education” was invented by Paulo Freire in an effort to depict the deductions of the modern-day educational system. Much unfavorable judgment has been addressed towards this work ; much truth the work has besides revealed. It is hard to reason. whether the writer was wholly right or incorrect – his premises have solid practical bases but can besides be debated. However. it is still interesting and utile to reexamine Freire’s statements as for what banking instruction is.
Need essay sample on Paulo Freire “The Banking Concept of…
specifically for you for only $12.90/page
The Banking construct of instruction
The kernel of the banking construct of instruction created by Freire is in the fact that pupils do non get and utilize cognition to analyse ; the cognition alternatively is merely deposited into them by the instructor. This procedure if viewed by Freire as the agency of impeding creativeness in instruction in general. “This is the banking construct of instruction. in which the range of action allowed to the pupils extends merely every bit far as having. filing. and hive awaying the deposits” ( Freire ) . Of class. one may reason that we ourselves are the Godheads of our instruction. and our cognition. However. enterprise in instruction is non ever applicable. particularly when the educational environment does non let any creativeness. as Freire tries to carry us. Therefore. the writer of the banking construct in instruction attempts to turn out that finally. pupils can non transform the deposited cognition. as they are non taught to use their transformational accomplishments.
“In the banking construct of instruction. cognition is a gift bestowed by those who consider themselves knowing upon those whom they consider to cognize nothing” ( Freire ) . As a effect. Freire speaks about “banking” instructors as oppressors. mentioning to the present educational system as “oppressing” . The cognition has ever been the procedure of enquiry. but the banking attacks in instruction alteration these thoughts. and do instruction similar to the suppressing political orientations: the instructor represents himself as opposed to his pupils. and they do non hold any pick to alter this or to get away this resistance. In the banking construct of instruction. pupils have to take their instructors for granted. and as people who know everything. while the pupils know nil ( Freire ) . The major contradiction of the banking instruction Freire depicts in the list of 10 attitudes and patterns of conventional instruction.
We have already mentioned the two of these attitudes. when the cognition is simply deposited into pupils. and when they are accepted by instructors as cognizing nil. Freire assumes that in his attack towards instruction. “the teacher thinks and the pupils are thought about” ( Freire ) . However. it is hard to understand here. in what manner the pupils are being thought of and how it relates to the discussed theoretical model. Does this mean that the pupils are thought about every bit simply the depositories of cognition? This premise can be right in the visible radiation of the already discussed issues. “The teacher negotiations and the pupils listen – meekly ; the instructor subjects and the pupils are disciplined” ( Freire ) . Obviously. the subjugation about which Freire speaks is besides reflected in the fact that pupils are non taken as the sensible objects that are capable of analysing and transforming this cognition. The subjugation is noticed in the state of affairs. when the pupils are non merely invariably disciplined by their instructors. but when they besides have to follow with the picks enforced by the instructor ( Freire ) . Many of us retrieve the state of affairss. when we had to work on the subject chosen by the coach without any possibility to discourse or alter it. Despite the nonsubjective nisus of the present educational system towards flexibleness. the figure of “oppression” illustrations is excessively big to do this “flexibility goal” at least closer.
“The oppressors use their “humanitarianism” to continue a profitable state of affairs. Therefore they react about instinctively against any experiment in instruction which stimulates the critical modules and is non content with a partial reappraisal of reality” ( Freire ) .
The kernel of these oppressors should be decently understood. and Freire makes particular accent on this apprehension: the oppressors ( instructors ) tend to alter the consciousness of the oppressed ( the pupils ) and non the state of affairs. which is called as “oppressive” . The subjugation to creativeness – this is the footing of the banking attack in instruction ; Freire describes a simple illustration in big instruction: “students will ne’er be proposed to critically see reality” ( Freire ) . Beyer is really enlightening in how he analyzes Freire’s construct: “Freire believes this is a signifier of subjugation in that pupils can non see the universe as they wish but alternatively are forced to see the universe in a mode that is approved by those in power” ( 98 ) .
Freire creates a distinguishable resistance between the banking instruction and problem-posing instruction. He obviously supports problem-posing construct for its capacity to decide the contradiction between the instructor and the pupils. when the instructor takes the place superior to that of pupils: “the instructor is no longer simply the-one-who-teaches. but one who is himself taught in duologue with the students” ( Freire ) . Therefore. the problem-posing instruction is the look of Freire’s thoughts as for what instruction should be and what organize it should take. Education should non take the mere signifier of person being taught by person who pretends he knows more ; instruction should be created in the procedure when the teacher’s authorization is no longer valid. As a consequence. the procedures of instruction and development take topographic point in changeless interaction between the pupils and the instructor.
It is possible to propose that Freire has gone beyond the traditional bounds of treatment within the subject of instruction. “He is besides reasoning that the manner of dealingss between instructor and pupil are of import determining relationships for how to be toward each other as humans” ( Beyer 103 ) . We ourselves have become the informants of the state of affairss. when instructors tended to stress their superior place towards us. We besides know how it hurts to understand that the instructor does non take us as equal. This may go a serious obstruction on the manner towards understanding between the instructor and the pupil. and as a consequence. on the manner towards effectual instruction.
Permanence and alteration are besides used by Freire as the two determiners of banking and problem-posing instruction:
“The banking method emphasizes permanency and becomes reactionist ; problem-posing instruction – which accepts neither a “well-behaved” present nor a preset fixture – roots itself in the dynamic present and becomes revolutionary” ( Freire ) .
Therefore. permanency and alteration are the two basic determiners. one of which ( permanency ) determines banking instruction as oppressive towards alteration and creativeness. and the other one ( alteration ) is the basic characteristic of good problem-posing instruction. The dramatic difference between the problem-posing and the banking construct of instruction is in the fact that. as Freire puts it. the banking construct does non let the individual thought of his state of affairs critically. It instead imposes fatalistic perceptual experience of any life state of affairs. The problem-posing attack. on the contrary. represents any state of affairs as a job. which needs analysis and solution. It is doubtless. that the banking construct is the look of the educational subjugation against those who seek creativeness and personal development.
Freire’s work is interesting in footings of clear designation of the issues. which do be in modern-day instruction. Despite the fact that Freire sometimes uses instead extremist footings. his initial purpose was to stand for the current system of instruction as it was. Furthermore. even understanding that we tend to present flexibleness and problem-posing approached into instruction. there is still much to be done in order to wholly extinguish banking attacks in instruction.
Beyer. L. E. A ; Apple. M. W.The Curriculum: Problems. Politics. and Possibilities.Capital of new york:
State University of New York Press. 1998.
Freire. P.Teaching method of the Oppressed.Chapter 2. 1993. Webster Philosophy Department. 17
November 2007. hypertext transfer protocol: //www. Webster. edu/~corbetre/philosophy/education/freire/freire-2. hypertext markup language
TOP ESSAY CATEGORIES
- Political Science
- Medical and Health
- Computer and Technology
- Academia and Classroom
- Academia and Students
- Academia and Text Matching Software
- Talent management in academia: performance systems
- Orientation Week
- College Student’s Pride toward Their Respective Schools
- APES FOOD LAB
- FINAL final Essay
- Organisational Transformation in Practice
- Evaluation of Critical Theory in Tourism
Research Paper Topics
Atlantic Slave Trade
Benjamin Franklin Flashcards
Fugitive Slave Law
Gettysburg Address Flashcards
Marshall Plan Flashcards
Populist Party Flashcards
Trail Of Tears
Trail of Tears Flashcards
Whiskey Rebellion Flashcards
Haven’t found what you want?
Get your custom essay sample
Let us write you a custom essay sample
Hey! So you need an essay done? We have something that you might like – do you want to check it out?
Check it out